I’m prepared for Chamisa − Chigumba

Turning to the opposition’s claims that there have been over 700 000 unaccounted for votes, Chigumba mentioned Chamisa had additionally gotten his mathematical calculations mistaken.

“… the 700 000 votes that the applicant alleges are unaccounted for are instantly resultant upon the usage of 72% as the ultimate voter turnout within the presidential election and never the right 85,1%. Moreover, the determine that the applicant comes up with, 4 032 000, as 72% of the whole voter inhabitants contains, by needed implication, each vote that will be forged in a presidential ballot together with votes that will, on the depend, be deemed to be invalid for one motive or one other. The figures he signifies as the whole votes forged from the introduced outcomes, 4 775 640, and from the info on the electoral fee’s CD, 4 774 878, each mirror the whole legitimate votes forged by way of the bulletins and the info on the CD,” Chigumba mentioned.

“The 4 032 000 on the one hand and the 4 775 640 and 4 774 878 on the opposite are thus totals representing two totally different sorts of issues the previous together with each legitimate and invalid vote and the latter solely the legitimate votes. The applicant then proceeds to subtract, in flip, the 2 parts of the latter class of votes from the previous class of votes thus yielding in every occasion the 700 000 alleged unaccounted votes with out taking account, in that computation, of the distinction between the 2 issues he has subtracted from one another.”

Chigumba additionally mentioned the method of collation and verification of the presidential outcomes was accomplished transparently, whereas Chamisa’s brokers, Morgen Komichi and Jameson Timba “had full entry to the outcomes collation”.

“The collation of the outcomes of some polling stations twice was a knowledge seize error whose extent has no materials impact on the outcomes of the presidential election. After correction of the double entries the primary respondent (Mnangagwa) nonetheless meets the statutory thresholds of 50% plus 1,” she mentioned including: “… the method of collation and verification of the presidential outcomes was accomplished transparently, and the applicant’s brokers Mr Morgen Komichi and Jameson Timba had full entry to the outcomes collation on the electoral fee’s nationwide command centre.

“As already averred Mr Timba throughout this course of, had event to request V11 and V23 types for a number of constituencies, he examined these types and made no matter notes he wished to make, he didn’t increase any queries with respect to these V11 or V23s … the provisions of part 110 of the Electoral Act are such that the absence of any candidate or his/her election agent doesn’t cease the method prescribed in that part from continuing to its conclusion.”

Commenting on the V11 and V23 types deadlock, Chigumba mentioned each political get together had entry to the types as and once they requested for them however castigated Chamisa for sourcing V11 types data on social media.

“Applicant additionally alludes to having sourced the V11 types from social media, suffice to remind him {that a} v11 type is obtained via the availability of part 64(1) (d1) of the Electoral Act. The authenticity of his supply of information is thus unsure,” she mentioned.

“As I’ve already averred, over the 2 day interval, the applicant’s brokers had limitless entry to all the unique V11 and V23 types referring to the presidential election and had the chance, at their discretion, to make notes from these V11 and V23 types or to lift any queries with the electoral fee officers the place that they had issues with the knowledge that was on the V11 and V23s being utilized by the electoral fee versus what that they had via their very own election brokers from varied polling

“Absolutely, if the applicant had polling brokers on the unidentified polling stations he alleges didn’t have returns affixed, these brokers would have been given V11 types earlier than the return for the polling station is affixed by way of the legislation. The applicant doesn’t on this context current his V11 types and contends that the V11 types that the electoral fee has are totally different from what he has …”

The Zec boss additional mentioned Chamisa didn’t point out at which polling stations he alleges the election returns weren’t affixed and neither did he clarify as as to whether he had polling brokers stationed at such polling stations, and if that’s the case, why no affidavits have been deposed to by such brokers in help of his averments that 21% of polling stations weren’t affixed by way of the legislation.

“Having made the allegations the applicant was enjoined to show it in his founding papers; he has failed to take action … the conclusion made by the applicant, from this naked allegation, is that the electoral fee rigged the presidential election with no proof furnished and no rationalization given as to how the alleged rigging is claimed to have taken place,” she mentioned.

“An utility in movement proceedings should make out his full case in his founding affidavit and if, as he has accomplished herein, he makes bald and unsubstantiated allegations, his utility can not presumably succeed.”

She urged the ConCourt to dismiss Chamisa’s utility on the premise that it had not been filed by way of part 93 of the Structure as learn with the ConCourt guidelines, 2016.
“No legitimate utility has been filed by the applicant difficult the election of the primary respondent to the workplace of the President of the Republic of Zimbabwe, by way of part 93 of the Structure as learn with the ConCourt guidelines, 2016,” the Zec chair mentioned.

“When it comes to part 93(1) of the Structure, a problem to the validity of an election to the workplace of the President is instituted by means of a petition or utility lodged with the ConCourt inside seven days after the date of the declaration of the outcomes of the election. Being a interval prescribed by statute, the seven-day supplied by part 93(1) of the Structure are reckoned with the inclusion of Saturdays, Sundays and public holidays. The time for lodging a petition by way of part 93(1) thus expired on the 10th of August 2018.”

“… Being peremptorily restricted to the interval of seven days after the declaration of the results of the election, any submitting and/or service that’s accomplished outdoors that timeframe is, accordingly, invalid with the correlative impact of rendering the whole utility fatally and incurably faulty.”

Commenting on the alleged disappearance of polling stations on the polling date, Chigumba mentioned: “No polling station disappeared on the polling day. The applicant doesn’t state the names of the polling stations that he alleges to have disappeared on the polling day. No polling stations had been created on the polling day. 1HRDC and 2HRDC that the applicant cites as examples of created polling stations are the truth is not polling stations. The previous stands for ward 1 Hurungwe Rural District Council and the latter stands for ward 2 Hurungwe Rural District Council.”

Author: Takudzwa Abioye

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *